12.2 million players can be mistaken, evidently.
Image credit: Eurogamer
Sony has triumphed over a significant £2 billion UK class action lawsuit regarding the cost of games on the PlayStation Store (appreciated, TheGameBusiness). The ruling emerged following a 30-day Competition Appeal Tribunal held in London, wherein PlayStation users alleged that Sony had eliminated “all real and possible competition” pertaining to the sale of digital games on the console.
The lawsuit, initiated by Alex Neill, who claimed to represent approximately 12.2 million players, charged Sony with imposing “exorbitant and unjust” prices on games offered in the storefront available through PS3, PS4, and PS5 consoles – the PlayStation Store. In a ruling released by London’s Competition Appeal Tribunal today (17th November), the case was dismissed. The ruling indicated that the market definitions utilized to characterize Sony’s behavior were “unreliable” and that consumers “were likely to make knowledgeable choices when buying consoles” and games on the hardware, as well.
PlayStation 5 – Official ‘It Happens On PS5’ Trailer
“Potential PlayStation console buyers had both access to ample information and a motivation to contemplate that information to make informed purchasing judgments at the console level, particularly for high-value users who invest considerable amounts in the digital gaming aftermarket,” stated the ruling.
The lawsuit contended that, upon acquiring a PS5 or other PlayStation console, consumers were subsequently confined within its ecosystem, compelled to accept the prices set by Sony. The Tribunal, however, disagreed and determined that Sony competed within a broader ‘systems market’ alongside Xbox, Nintendo, and PC, for instance. Moreover, the Tribunal found no evidence that the presence of alternative digital storefronts would have actually reduced any PlayStation Store prices.
Interestingly, the Tribunal pointed out that customers can also choose and purchase physical games rather than utilizing the PlayStation Store – an approach that is set to change at the beginning of 2028. This did not appear to impact today’s decision,