Limitations that focus on loot boxes and pay-to-win may end up having extensive consequences beyond mobile
Image credit: Marco on Unsplash
The European Commission’s release of its preliminary Digital Fairness Act (DFA) last week incited a reaction within the gaming sector, with many prominent individuals openly voicing their apprehensions. Perspectives in the broader industry were more tempered, possibly due to the fact that some of the practices targeted by the DFA – like loot boxes or pay-to-win – are financially lucrative, yet not universally favored by gamers.
The proposed ramifications of the DFA would extend well beyond less-popular free-to-play features, significantly influencing game development. Certain individuals are cautioning that the European sector would be especially impacted. An evaluation of the draft reveals several stipulations that could present difficulties for European creators, along with considerable risks for substantial financial repercussions.
Key provisions
Let’s begin with the stipulations concerning purchased virtual currencies (Art. 14). It’s crucial to understand that this designation encompasses not only currencies acquired directly through real-world money, but also those obtained indirectly – that is, secondary currencies within the game. Whenever virtual items or other goods can be obtained using purchased virtual currencies, companies will need to display their corresponding cash value in actual currency.
This is not a novel request, but it can be complicated to execute. When purchased, it’s quite obvious that the publisher must indicate what the user needs to pay in real money. The DFA surpasses that requirement and mandates that the “value” in real currency is also shown when the virtual currency is utilized.
So, what’s the issue with this? First: How should the conversion be calculated when virtual currency can be bought as well as earned through gameplay? Second: If the virtual currency is spent during core gameplay, it is anything but immersive to present anything in real-world cash: Picture a medieval fantasy MMOG where a player utilizes virtual gold to acquire a virtual sword, and the NPC merchant must announce the item’s cost in Euros.