(Image credit: Rockstar Games)
The three interchangeable characters in GTA 5 were determined “right at the outset” of production, but Rockstar always realized that the concept “could potentially fail.”
In an interview with Edge Magazine back in 2013, Aaron Garbut – who was the art director on GTA 5 and is currently co-studio head overseeing GTA 6 – stated that Rockstar was aware from the start that “we aimed to incorporate three interchangeable characters.” However, even after the studio had formulated those characters along with the ambiance of their game, Garbut mentioned that “the initial concept” for the game remained “quite unpolished.”
Ultimately, Rockstar “merely developed and adapted and allowed the game to shape its own direction,” yet Garbut admitted that “[having] several characters was a gamble. It was a captivating concept, and it felt as if we could accomplish intriguing things with it, but it also seemed like a deviation from the essence of the game that might fail.” Fortunately, the trio of Michael, Trevor, and Franklin “turned out exceptionally” – but Garbut confessed he wasn’t convinced that would happen until after the game was released.
“It’s extremely difficult during production to gain perspective,” he stated. “You become so accustomed to looking for issues that it almost becomes unfeasible to step back and recognize the advantages. Throughout this project, despite being immersed in that universe for years, replaying the missions consistently, it felt enjoyable. It was thrilling to explore the world, to witness its evolution from rudimentary building blocks to the elaborate finished product featuring all the scenarios and life incorporated.”
I can certainly envision that in the lead-up to GTA 5, the trio of protagonists may have caused a few restless nights at Rockstar. Firstly, the studio was deviating from its typical pattern – consisting of a single protagonist surrounded by a large and eccentric ensemble of supporting characters. Secondly, it was extending an immense narrative among those three, requesting the audience to follow a continually shifting narrative viewpoint. Third, and perhaps most crucially, it was genuinely putting the hardware of that time to the test – GTA 5 was released on PS3,