Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy is currently available, delivering 4K graphics to the 2023 release along with the newly introduced Dandori Academy mode and some cool additional features like voice commands.
We assigned it a rating of 7/10 in our review. It remains enjoyable – indeed, the primary Pikmin 4 storyline might be the finest of the series – yet we can’t ignore our discontent regarding the absence of mouse controls and 60fps performance.
However, if you glance at Metacritic, you’d believe Nintendo merely released its most disappointing game in recent years. While the metascore stands at an impressive 83, the user score for the game is significantly, significantly lower at 2.3. This effectively indicates an average rating of ‘Generally Unfavorable’. Yikes.
So what’s the issue?
Many individuals appear to be dissatisfied with the idea that Nintendo is charging for what they view as a very minimal enhancement over the original. It’s accurate that numerous titles over the years have received complimentary updates for newer systems, but Nintendo has chosen to impose a fee of £7.99 / $9.99 / €9.99.
One user remarked:
“This Switch 2 edition is practically useless. At best, it’s an insult to fans of the series. $20 AUD for a collection of recycled content and 4K graphics. They couldn’t even take the initiative to incorporate 60fps even though the hardware could undoubtedly support it. Such a careless update, and yet they dare to charge $20 AUD.”
Meanwhile, another user offered a somewhat more balanced critique, stating:
“The Dandori Academy consists of reused content, half of the maps presented so far are directly lifted from the base game and the other half replicate the identical layout. Additionally, the new card on the title screen resembles an advertisement, spoiling the lovely landscape, fortunately, it can be concealed.
“The main game has also been impacted, now somehow exhibiting longer loading times than it did on the original Switch.